Why more thought leadership isn’t helping you win more business

Article Highlights:

  • Buyers of complex services need evidence that your firm understands their problem, has done relevant work, and can make sound decisions before they engage sales.
  • AI makes it easy to scale thought-leadership output, but more activity does little if the articles it produces don’t reduce the buyer’s uncertainty about hiring the firm.
  • Thought leadership helps sales when it contains expertise, showing how practitioners think, diagnose problems, and make decisions.
  • You can extract practitioner expertise and turn it into a sales asset through a structured interview or by using our DIY process.

Generating new business is harder for expert-led firms.

Meanwhile, they’re seeing fewer expansion opportunities and partner referrals. Armed with AI, these firms are doing what seems logical: more outbound, more campaigns, more thought leadership.

But more activity doesn’t solve the underlying buying problem.

Buyers of complex services don’t want to fuck up. They don’t want to be the person who championed a $750,000 implementation project that created a ton of disruption and had no positive impact on the business. 

And there are plenty of examples of those.

So, they need to reduce risk before they decide to work with your firm. That’s why they want evidence your team understands their specific problem, has done relevant work before, and has seen a positive ROI before they pull the trigger.

Buyers Evaluate Your Expertise Before Contacting Sales

Time for some radical candor.

Most expert-led service firms have closed deals despite themselves. They may think they have a strong sales and marketing function, but tighter budgets and AI have exposed a very different reality. 

The truth is that for the longest time, firms had the advantage. Buyers found it difficult to evaluate firms. Being present counted for expertise. There was a lot less scrutiny over budgets. And most firms had small marketing teams competing against other firms doing very little marketing. Simply doing “something” could put you ahead of competitors.

Founders and senior practitioners would step into deals and carry the credibility burden themselves. The mantra was, “We just need to get them on the call, and we can close.”

That ship has sailed.

Firms that thought they had a working sales process and did “enough” marketing are struggling to close new business for several reasons.

Buyers do more research before they ever speak with sales. AI has accelerated that shift because buyers can describe their situation in far more detail than they could with traditional search.

For example,

We’re a financial services company running Red Hat Ansible Automation Platform and Dynatrace across a hybrid environment. We want to use Dynatrace events to trigger Event-Driven Ansible workflows for automated incident remediation, while keeping human approval for higher-risk production changes.

We need a Red Hat consulting partner that has implemented this kind of Ansible and Dynatrace integration in production, not just general Ansible experience. They should be able to help with the architecture, Event-Driven Ansible rulebooks and playbooks, remediation workflows, governance, and rollout.

Which firms should we shortlist? For each firm, show evidence of its Red Hat relationship, relevant Ansible and Dynatrace implementation experience, comparable client work or case studies, and whether it supports enterprise customers in the U.S.

They can also add industry, technology, geography, partner ecosystem, company size, or other constraints to narrow the field quickly.

That’s much more granular than before, when buyers had to research the space to uncover the keywords they’d use to find partners (one reason referrals were the main business driver).

Saying your firm “specializes in enterprise automation” tells buyers very little. 

They want evidence that you:

  • Understand the specific problem
  • Have worked with the relevant technologies in comparable environments
  • Have achieved success with this kind of work before 

Buyers Want Evidence That You

1

Understand the specific problem

2

Have worked with the relevant technologies in comparable environments

3

Have achieved success with this kind of work before

No one wants to pay to be your guinea pig.

So when that evidence isn’t available, the burden shifts back onto sales.  

The seller has to bring in a partner, architect, consultant, or founder who can explain the nuance (when they have time on their schedule). The buyer waits. The deal slows. The firm stays dependent on direct access to senior expertise. And often, the project defaults to indecision because it’s simply TOO RISKY for the buyer to champion.

We see this across expert-led firms: fewer dependable referrals, longer sales cycles, more demands for specific evidence of expertise and impact, and more deals that need a senior practitioner involved before the buyer is comfortable progressing.

Relying on AI Alone Won’t Fix Your Pipeline

When net-new business gets harder, the instinct is to do more.

More outbound.

More messages.

More campaigns.

More articles.

AI makes scaling possible. I’m seeing firms that used to publish once or twice a quarter produce six to ten articles a month.

Great…right?

The articles are competent: organized, comprehensive, and accurate. So why are they still struggling to generate new business?

Because the assumption is: if we produce more, more people will see us, and more opportunities will follow.

AI has removed a production constraint, but that doesn’t mean production was the constraint holding sales back. Firms can now create far more activity, far more quickly, without first asking whether buyers lacked volume or evidence.

That logic comes largely from a dated view of SaaS marketing—a mindset that has derailed many marketing investments over the years.

More Output Doesn’t Reduce the Risk of Buying a Service

SaaS companies rely primarily on visibility around pain points to drive someone into a funnel, show them the product, give them a demo, and get them into a free trial.

Complex services don’t work that way.

Not remotely.

There’s no product to trial, no features to review, and no dashboards to share. 

The buyer makes a bet on whether the people behind the firm understand their situation, make good decisions, and deliver an outcome they can’t fully inspect in advance.

That means your website needs to showcase your firm’s judgment. 

Visibility does very little.

Worse, knowledge-focused content is less effective than it used to be. 

For example, technology-services firms used to prove expertise by publishing detailed knowledge-base articles. Today, buyers can answer these questions themselves through embedded copilots and general-purpose AI without ever seeing your firm.

So that content does very little.

By the time they come to a consulting firm, the question is often narrower:

Can you solve this specific problem in our environment, and what evidence do you have that you’ve done something similar before?

Publishing more competent “thought leadership” doesn’t answer that question (more on competent vs. sales-ready thought leadership shortly).

It just gives the firm more chances to publish something that still doesn’t help the buyer evaluate the firm.

Competent vs Sales-Ready Thought Leadership

At first glance, the AI-generated “thought leadership” I see firms publish isn’t “bad.” It’s competent. 

It explains the topic, organizes the argument, summarizes common recommendations, and produces a useful-looking article. 

But it lacks the one thing buyers need to make your service feel less risky: your firm’s judgment. 

The only difference between the asset you publish and something completely created by an in-house marketer or agency with AI is the byline. 

And that’s the problem.

Buyers want a sample of the service before the sale. They need to see the fingerprints of the people who would do the work:

  • What have they seen before?
  • What do they notice that someone without their experience might miss?
  • How do they diagnose the problem?
  • Where does the standard recommendation break?
  • What tradeoffs change their advice?
  • How do they decide what to do next?

We recently reviewed an article from a technology consulting firm that was coherent, practical, and technically sound. It identified several common reasons expensive AI infrastructure can sit idle, recommended readiness work before deployment, and gave buyers questions to ask before the next order.

There was nothing technically wrong with it.

But a marketer could have created it using AI.

The buyer isn’t trying to determine whether your firm can explain the topic. They’re trying to determine whether your practitioners have the experience and judgment to solve their problem. If the article doesn’t reveal practitioner judgment, it adds little value in helping the buyer evaluate your firm.

Your firm stays indistinguishable from other firms. And your firm stays dependent on dragging SMEs into sales calls to prove expertise.

Competent thought leadership Thought leadership for sales
Explains the topic Helps the buyer see how you think
Summarizes general recommendations Exposes reasoning behind the recommendation
Uses information available across the market Contains experience, distinctions, examples, and judgment that belong to the practitioner
Demonstrates familiarity Reduces uncertainty about hiring the firm
Gives marketing something to publish Gives sales and partners something useful in a specific buyer conversation

You can use AI to make both types of articles.

The difference is whether you let AI create generic assets by filling gaps with widely accessible information, or use AI to extract and package your firm’s expertise into assets buyers can use.

You want to do the second one.

“

Buyers want a sample of the service before the sale.

Build Thought Leadership and Proof for Sales Instead

We worked with a technology consulting firm running VMware migrations that wanted to capitalize on growing discontent with the platform after rate hikes.

The project started with case studies highlighting the firm’s work. After we created a couple of assets, we worked with their chief architect to create thought leadership articles on the importance of infrastructure agility, tied to their work and the growing discontent in the space as SaaS platforms increased rates.

They shared those assets on LinkedIn, attracting partner managers, existing clients, and buyers facing the same challenges. The assets also helped frame their presentation at a co-branded event.

The assets aligned their team, helped frame sales conversations, and gave sellers value when following up with sales leads.

We also saw an uptick in leads from AI tools and search.

If we were creating competent thought leadership, we’d have stopped at covering the risks of vendor lock-in or concerns about VMware pricing.

Two Ways to Create Thought Leadership for Sales

There are two practical ways to create thought leadership for sales.

You can interview the practitioner to extract and shape their expertise into a sales asset. Or, your team (SME alone or SME + marketer) can work through a structured AI process themselves.

The principle for both is the same: start with a buyer or sales question to surface current practitioner judgment that makes the firm easier to evaluate.

Interview-driven The DIY System
Who owns the process In-house marketer (or Practical Revenue) The SME or marketer running the system
How expertise gets extracted Structured conversation with SME using approved outline and questions AI asks targeted questions and flags missing judgment as the article develops
SME involvement 30-mins ideation chat to flesh out the article; 60-mins interview; 30 mins for draft review and edits SME works through the article directly and supplies judgment when prompted
AI’s role Supports research, outlining, interview-question development, transcript analysis, and drafting. Handles research, analysis, structure, drafting, revision, and verification
Best fit SMEs who want someone else to own the extraction and development process SMEs or marketers who want to run the process themselves
End goal Sales-ready thought leadership built from practitioner expertise Same

Interview-Driven Thought Leadership

You can run an interview-driven process internally or have someone else own it.

The process is straightforward:

  1. Start with the sales use case: Identify the buyer question, objection, or decision the asset needs to support.
  2. Choose the right practitioner: Interview the person closest to the work and the judgment behind it.
  3. Extract the expertise: Focus the conversation on what they’ve seen, the decisions they made, the risks and tradeoffs involved, and the outcomes.
  4. Build the article from the interview: Shape the practitioner’s input into a clear argument tied to the buyer problem.
  5. Review with the SME: Confirm the judgment, accuracy, and voice.
  6. Publish and distribute: Share it in follow-up, proposals, campaigns, partner conversations, or wherever the original buyer question appears.

If you run this internally, make sure the interview goes beyond simply extracting knowledge. The last thing you want is to waste SME time creating an asset your marketing team could have made with AI.

You want a debatable POV tied to recent buyer questions or market trends, ideally tied to current projects.

This is what Practical Revenue runs for expert-led firms that want someone to own the outlining, interviewing, and development of the asset.

DIY System: Thought Leadership for Sales

The other option is to run that process yourself without the interview.

Just don’t ask your AI to write an article on a topic. That’s the exact failure mode this entire piece is trying to help you avoid…

Instead, follow a structured process with your AI to extract your expertise. To make that easier, we’ve created a DIY process based on our methodology.

The DIY System: Thought Leadership for Sales takes you through five stages:

  1. Test: Research the SME, firm, relevant work, and market context, then test whether the idea or existing article contains enough practitioner judgment to be worth developing.
  2. Set the path: Determine whether the article is ready, needs targeted changes, needs broader redevelopment, or needs more SME input.
  3. Develop: Set the article direction, identify missing expertise, and build or revise the structure.
  4. Draft or revise: Work through the article section by section, with AI asking for practitioner judgment whenever the existing material isn’t strong enough.
  5. Finalize: Review the complete article, write the intro from the finished body, verify the claims, and prepare the asset for publication.

Throughout the process, the system asks for more practitioner input or leaves the gap visible. It doesn’t fill the space with plausible AI reasoning.

So you don’t end up with something that’s merely “competent.”

The trade-off is that the SME still has to supply the judgment, and no human interviewer is there to help you dig deeper into your expertise. 

But you can offset that by running the DIY with your in-house marketer (ideally while on a call).

Either way, the goal is the same: extract expertise from your practitioners and turn it into an asset your buyers can use to sample your service before the sale.

James De Roche

James De Roche runs Practical Revenue, helping founders at B2B services firms stop babysitting deals by putting a revenue system in place that teams can run without constant founder rescue.

He’s spent a decade inside services sales and marketing teams, seeing where deals stall and building an approach that gets sales, marketing, and delivery working together to reduce founder-dependent revenue.

Practical Revenue helps B2B services firms reduce the Founder Tax through Audit, Install, and Governance.